letters
from the ashtanga yoga forum on Yahoogroups: |
| Q:
Do you guys think that it would be helpful to do some heavy
military presses to build up my shoulder strength help me be
able to do poses that require strong shoulders?
I just got David Swensons DVD on the short forms. I am really
inspired after watching the 'demo'. That man is amazing.Also,
I'm 36 and pretty stiff. Can anyone eventually become flexible
like David with enought time and practice or are certain people
genetically gifted to the point that others that are not will
never be able to atain the same flexibility?
I know most people say Yoga isn't competitive and to do the
poses to your best ability without pushing to the point of injury,
but some poses simply require a high degree of flexibility to
do correctly. I'm just wondering if I should expect to be able
to do all the poses if I take the right steps and give it time.Are
there any people here who started off as someone who was relitivly
stiff and is now relitivily flexible? I mean has made huge gains
over time?
- John
A: Hello John,
I have been practising 2nd series for three years now and I
understand your frustration. I too was also very stiff (still
am I think). Don't worry about where you are with your practise,
let it go. Be in the moment and feel what your body can do on
a day to day basis. If you are experiencing stiffness in your
postures you are benefiting just as much as someone who is very
loose and feels stiffness in harder postures if that makes sense.
Don't do weights to build your strength, this is not yoga,
its holistic not the latest fitness craze from the US. You may
build strength in your shoulder but the universe will balance
your out in creating as much strength you gained in the form
of stiffness in your shoulder which will hinder your practise.
The quickest way for me to soften my body was to soften my
mind through meditation, this is the answer. So don't compare
yourself to others, love your stiffness and it will dissolve.
Take care my friend
A: John,
If you must build strength in your upper body then use exercises
that involve your OWN body weight - stay away from the weights
and machines in the gym - this will hinder your flexibility.
Having said that if you stick with your Ashtanga practice and
your frequency is at least 3 times per week then your strength
will come naturally.
DON'T DO MILLITARY PRESSES - it will cause bunching and shortening
of the fascia surrounding the muscle tissue and your flexibility
will suffer (in fact this is true of any weight training exercises
+ running too).
If you must, then one of the best general upper body strength
exercises you can do is dip's - lift yourself between parallel
bars or improvise with 2 chairs, and lower yourself down slowly
and then back up again. This will not isolate any muscles (which
tends to cause imbalance in the body) and give your whole upper
body (arms, shoulders, chest) a good workover - if done properly
it's a tough exercise though.
If you want to give your flexibility/stiffness a jump start
then look into getting some structural integration bodywork
done like Rolfing or Hellerwork - painful and intense but well
worth it!
I'm 30 and have been practicing for a year now (3/4 times per
week) and came from a weights/wrestling background - my hip
flexibility was terrible, the Hellerwork has really helped,
I've still got a long way to go, but I'm on the right path and
accept it will take time.
Hope that helps |
Q:
I am new here. Honestly I had never heard of this type of Yoga
before. I learned about it a really silly way. I recently saw
Madonna in a movie and wondered how she stays so lean and buff
so I did a search and saw she does this type of Yoga.
I am new to ALL types of Yoga so was wondering what exactly
it is. I am relatively out of shape. I have been doing Pilates
for awhile though and so am more strong through my abs. I would
like to join a gym when I get enough money and so I thought
getting cardio that way and doing Yoga/Pilates would be good
for getting the leaner longer look. What do you think?
A: Madonna's Astanga teacher is also my teacher.
Lean is a function of what one eats. Buff could be one of the
many benifits of Astanga. The Astanga Primary Series releases
the toxins in the body, can't really say that about Pilates.
It's doubtful that you can find a Pure Astanga class at the
gym. You should find a qualified teacher if you can depending
on where you live, perhaps you could share that with the group.
Good Luck,
BH |
Hi,
I've been doing Ashtanga Primary for the past 3 years, and started
doing Pilates (mat & machine Allegro) regularly for the
past few months. My first Yoga class was at the gym. It was
crowded and with the music and lots of fun. I got lean due to
overall exercise amount and was happy with my physical fitness....
up until I went to my first Ashtanga class in Yoga Studio settings.
MY GOD, the difference is pheonominal. Ashtanga differs from
other types of yoga, especially Iyengar or Yin where each pose
is held longer. In Ashtanga primary series, you go thru 70 plus
poses in 90 mins, with focus on breaths, gaze and bandhas (internal
body lock, almost like "scooping the tummy" "fannel
down the ribs" in Pilates terms). While breathing deep
and long, you are constantly moving. Perfect balance of Cardio,
weight (your own weight) training and endurance exercise. You
produce copious amount of sweat, naturally.
At the beginning, you feel really sore in your body, but in
keeping practicing regularly (recommended at least 3 times/week)
under a teacher supervision (if not, I recommend getting David
Swenson's Primary series DVD - helps tons) you are guaranteed
to reach your optimum health and fitness. I love the abs work
of Pilates and over all massages of the body & mind in Ashtanga.
I also go to the gym for quick cardio, do spinning clases,
combat, steps... etc All compliment to my health very well.
But, if you think you can do Yoga very well (whatever that means)
at the gym classes, then, it is a good time for you to challenge
yourself to enrol into one of Ashtanga classes in your neighbourhood.
I can assure you that it will be one of the best thing you can
do for your body & soul!
:) And, whatever you do.... Have Fun!
Sayoko Kamei |
Q:
I've been practicing the Ashtanga primary series for almost
2 years. I injured what I think is the connecting ligament between
my hamstring and the sitting bone. I was doing Supta Padangustasana
B and I think I got more help than I needed. That was 3 weeks
ago. I kept practicing, although I was holding back not wanting
to worsen my injury. I was hoping it would go away. Last Friday,
the pain was keeping me from doing many of the poses (that was
getting to be frustrating) so I decided to take a full break
from any physical activity for a few weeks. I also bike about
5-6 hours a week /road bike. I'm not sure if that was causing
things to get worse.
In any case, since I stopped all physical activity a week ago,
the pain/discomfort has been consistently increasing. I'm confused.
I was feeling better while I was practicing. Now, I feel much
stiffer and forward bends are more painful.
Should I start practicing again very slowly and not wait for
the pain to completely go away? Anyone with a similar experience?
Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
HF
A: Hi,
I have a similar injury... mine has been coming and going for
years. it seems that on the worst days i just can't stretch
that side as much as i used to/would like to, which creates
frustration. I find that if i keep practicing and not get tempted
to stretch that side (even if I'm very warm and it feels good)
after a while it goes away. the bad news (at least for me) is
that it never really goes away and i seem to forget about it
when its "cured" only to find that its there again
if i over do it.
I assume your biking is not so great for it as it makes that
muscle tighter and there for its more painful when u stretch
it in yoga. i wish i had a "cure" for u but I find
that its a dynamic thing and best thing to do is keep the practice
and avoid doing something that pains you. listen to your body
and in time it will go away. good luck.
-Noa
A: No great insights here, just throwing in
that I once had that injury as well (got it BOWLING for the
first time in 10 years!!), it was very persistent, painful and
annoying, hung around for quite a while, I had to lay back on
most physical activity for a while, it did eventually fully
vanish and has been gone for about 8 years now with no re-appearance.
I always thought it funny that in a life filled with motorcycling,
serious weightlifting, football, ashtanga practice, and quite
a bit of wild stuff, it was BOWLING that left me limping around
for a year! |
Q:
Please donÃt take this as an argument I am just
curious and open to learning. I hear people say that lifting
weights hinders yoga but lifting body weight doesn't.
How can say doing a handstand pushup develop the muscle differently
than a dumbbell press? You can actually achieve a great range
of motion with dumbbells. It seems like some people just are
saying things they have been told by other people with out really
researching.
Our muscles know how to contract. They don't know if they are
lifting the body weight or iron. Olympic lifters are actually
extremely flexible in their shoulders. They need to be for some
of the lifts they do.
I am very open to not dropping my weight lifting program and
have seen many posts about people who actually have felt from
first hand experience that lifting is hindering them. My current
strength-training program is 90% body weight exercises.
Just want to be clear that I'm not upset or defensive, just
trying to learn.
A: John,
From personal experience, I don't think weights necessarily
hindered my practice (I was an avid iron-pusher for almost a
decade, working out with amateur bodybuilders) but eventually
I lost the desire to go to the gym. Also, once my practice picked
up and became consistent (5-6x week), I found that fatigued
muscles from lifting made the practice difficult.
That said, I think it really depends on each individual and
what type of training they do. If, for example, one did lots
of plyometrics and light weights it may not hinder their practice
as much as it might for someone lifting quite heavy weights
and only using machines (rather than dumbbells, since, as you
stated - and I agree - dumbbells allow a greater range of motion).
Ultimately, I think it is up to the individual. Many purists
would disagree. I myself struggled for a long time because I
enjoy running - at least 50 or so miles per week. I thought
this would slow my "progress" but after speaking with
my teacher (who is authorized), I knew the two were not mutually
exclusive. In fact, running is just another way for me to practice
yoga. It may take me a while to go deeper in my practice, but
I would be quite unhappy to have to exclude one of these activities,
so I'm OK with that. You should listen to your own body - what
works for one doesn't necessarily work for another, so only
you will know what is best. Hope this helps...
Rayna |
For years
I was an incessant party animal. I'd make it to yoga when
I could, usually about once a week. Then after a particularly
difficult night of debauchery I decided it was time to get well.
I stopped drinking, practiced yoga about three times a week
and about 3 months into it I started have debilitating panic
attacks. There were moments I was too afraid to leave
my apartment. I stopped practicing yoga for about six
months. I was a mess trying to manage my anxiety with
a non-addictive prescription drug.
Finally I made it back to my mat. I just wanted to let
go of everything that was causing so much craziness in my life.
That is when it all began. I wanted to let go. There
were somedays it felt like yoga was going to bring me to my
knees. I felt so hollow inside and had such a sense of
desperation. I felt yoga was making me more depressed.
I eased up on some of the self help stuff I was doing, but knew
for some reason I needed to stick with yoga. There were
times, during savasana, that all I wanted to do was cry and
cry and cry.
One night, after a particularly tough emotional time during
yoga I went to bed quite early. I noticed that my chest
felt like it was on fire, but the rest of my body was cool.
I realized that my yoga practice, the building of my internal
heat and my desire to "just let go" was burning through
the negative emotions.
I still have my days. There are times I still want to
go out and party, but now I know I have the strength to seek
something better for myself. I cannot begin to describe,
in depth, how much yoga has changed my life. You have
no idea how much power is contained in the words "Practice
and all else is coming."
shanti,
Steven |
Q:
...what yogis do in the heavens once they die?!?!
A: Since they are already dead, there is
nothing they are attached to or have to strive for. I guess
its party time up there with buckets full of Amrutam ;)
Gayathri
P. S. I don't mean to offend anyone. Just some humor. |
Q:
I read these messages about people who have become vegetarian,
given up sugar and other things and I seem to have a difficult
time controlling similar aspects of my life - that has to do
with food and I guess also materialistic items as well.
My question is how do you go about making these changes and
has anybody out there really struggled with this and succeeded?
I appreciate with thanks any input from anyone on this.
Best,
H
A: Wake up in the morning. Have a bath. Pray.
Traditional Indian vegetarian breakfast
- Should make you slightly sleepy.
Then Practice Restorative Yoga.
Traditional full-course Indian vegetarian meal
- Should put you in a blissful 3-hour Savasana.
Practice Lazy-Boy Yoga.
Traditional Indian vegetarian snack/sweets
- Should make you hyperactive.
A full Ashtanga Practice session.
Traditional Indian vegetarian dinner
- This will definitely end the day with a 9 hour uninterrupted
Savasana.
Ok, do I see bricks/stones my way:-)))
Gayathri
A: This is not the final word on diet... but here is
what I do.
No meat
No dairy
Limited wheat intake
Green Tea
Take a BIG swig of flaxseed oil every day.
Multi vitamin
Breakfast: two bannanas, handfull of raw almonds
Lunch: Miso soup (Miso Master Red Miso) with Shitaki
Mushrooms and fresh tofu
Dinner: varies, veggie burger, Pad Thai, tacos, Soy
smoothie, Tofu stirfry
Cup of Bedtime tea from Yogi Teas... then off to bed at 9:00 |
Often when
you make major changes in your life, you have to go through
a period of rejecting the 'bad' things you did before (I know
I had to become a militant anti-smoker to be able to give up),
but these feelings are tools to help you get over your addictions
and habits. In time, they mellow and you can come to accept
the things you did, and they won't seem so terribly harmful
(after all, it only takes a few years for lungs to completely
recover from smoking for instance - the human body is amazingly
resilient!).
Try and have fun with your practice - maybe you can find a
friend to practice with, who you can laugh with and not get
too self-judgmental when practising. Enjoy what you can do without
thinking about what you should be able to do. It was a huge
moment for me when I realised I didn't have to be the healthiest,
strongest, most flexible, etc. and instead could just find it
fun that I can do headstands, handstands - like when I was a
child!
It seems to me that people can lose their humour when making
a significant improvements to their lifestyle, and then find
life dull. At first I felt I'd lost most of my social life,
and my opportunities to really enjoy myself, and yoga became
almost a punishment to me - I must practice six times a week
regardless of how I feel, after all the harm I've done to my
body! I think I've found a better balance now, I still spend
time with the friends I used to go out and drink and smoke with,
but we practice together, or swim together, or go out but without
drinking and smoking, having the same fun different ways. And
I love my practice now, but if I don't feel like doing it, I
won't. |
I've just
started with Ashtanga this week, and I hope no one minds if
I share a question. As I'm just trying it out for a while, I
haven't joined a class or anything, I'm just working out of
Beryl Bender Birch's book.
I've been working with Matt Furey's Combat Conditioning program
- ifyou're not familiar with it, it's not what it sounds like.
Matt is a former college wrestler (real wrestling, not modern
"professional" wrestling). Basically he started with
bodyweight exercises as performed by Hindu Wrestlers and has
expanded it to include lots of good old fashioned pushups, exercises
and postures from various martial arts and yoga, exercises performed
by the old-time strongmen and wrestlers (guys who worked out
before the whole weight-lifting craze), and he puts great emphasis
on proper breathing while doing the exercises.
I find that many of the postures of Ashtanga are easier for
me than for people who come from a weight-lifting background
due to the similarity of many of the postures and CC exercises
- particularly the upward and downward facing dog postures.
I find it interesting that Yoga espouses many of the same principles
that he has gleaned from breathing exercises of the old-time
strongmen. It seems there's nothing new in the world, and practicing
a regimen as old as yoga proves that. I wonder if many of those
strongmen of yesteryear got their breathing routines from yoga
or a
similar practice.
And naturally, that similarity is what led me to Ashtanga as
a next logical step. I hope to combine the two - Ashtanga and
Combat Conditioning - without compromising either one. I do
Ashtanga in the morning to get me going, then work on CC in
the evening after work. So far it's working nicely. |
Q:
Can somebody please tell me the meaning of the three
markings on Guruji's forehead?
A: The three markings on Guruji's forehead
are an indication of his commitment to his faith. In his case,
as I understand it, he is a devotee of Vishnu, one of the incarnations
of Krishna (the Supreme Godhead). The white markings are made
by clay from a particular sacred lake and are sometimes seen
on seven other points of the body. The marks are known as 'the
footprints of Vishnu' and mark his body as a Temple of God.
Other Hindus follow other practices, and the marks may be red,
and much smaller dots, located at different points on the forehead.
They all indicate that the Hindu has followed his or her devotional
practices that day.
|
|